A tariff scenario: prices, profits and revenue

A tariff changes consumer prices and the revenue retained by sellers. This guide asks how a tariff on one firm’s two products changes prices, physical profits and importing-government revenue. It assumes trade 0.9.0, a compatible antitrust >= 0.99.43 and coordination >= 0.1.0 are installed. All inputs below are illustrative; prices are currency per unit and inside size is units.

Solve a tariff scenario

specify() uses supplied structural parameters. as_trade_fit() copies the fitted game without recalibrating or solving it. simulate() solves the policy change. Firm A owns products a and b, so its choices account for both products.

A producer-value statutory rate t becomes the consumer-price fraction tau = t / (1 + t). Thus a statutory 25% tariff is .20, not .25, in this API.

library(trade)
source_owner <- setNames(c("A", "A", "B", "C"), c("a", "b", "c", "d"))
source_fit <- antitrust::specify(
  "logit", "bertrand", variant = "standard",
  prices = c(2, 2.2, 2.4, 2.6), ownerPre = unname(source_owner),
  insideSize = 100, labels = c("a", "b", "c", "d"),
  parameters = list(alpha = -1.5, meanval = c(3, 2.5, 2, 1.5))
)
policy_fit <- as_trade_fit(source_fit, tariffPre = 0,
  cost_basis = "effective", margin_basis = "net_revenue")
tau <- .25 / 1.25
scenario <- simulate(policy_fit, tariffPost = c(tau, tau, 0, 0))
pre <- tariff_accounts(scenario, preMerger = TRUE)
post <- tariff_accounts(scenario, preMerger = FALSE)
prices_output <- data.frame(
  product = post$product, firm = unname(source_owner[post$product]),
  canonical_firm = post$firm,
  price_pre = pre$price, price_post = post$price,
  price_change_pct = 100 * (post$price / pre$price - 1),
  q_pre = pre$q, q_post = post$q
)
knitr::kable(prices_output, digits = 3)
product firm canonical_firm price_pre price_post price_change_pct q_pre q_post
a A 1 2.0 2.064 3.186 57.407 55.468
b A 1 2.2 2.314 5.169 25.795 23.122
c B 2 2.4 2.403 0.139 11.590 12.261
d C 3 2.6 2.601 0.055 5.208 5.525

Read price_change_pct as a percentage relative to the stored fitted baseline. The q columns are quantities, not market shares. The original firm labels are retained by matching product IDs: canonical firm IDs 1/2/3 correspond to A/B/C in this example. Use the explicit mapping when exporting or joining firm data. Compare product a, which is tariffed, with product c, which is untariffed: rivals’ prices and quantities can respond even though their own tariff is zero. These supplied parameters are an illustrative scenario, not estimates from the displayed price vector.

Follow the money

Government receives tau * price * q; sellers retain (1-tau) * price * q. Physical unit cost excludes the tariff and is measured in currency per output unit. Multiply it by quantity to obtain total production cost. Net revenue, producer profit and government revenue are currency totals. Effective unit cost divides physical unit cost by retention; it is a pricing representation, not another payment.

product_accounts <- data.frame(product = post$product,
  physical_unit_cost = post$physical_cost,
  physical_total_cost = post$physical_cost * post$q,
  net_revenue = post$net_revenue, producer_profit = post$producer_profit,
  government_revenue = post$government_revenue)
knitr::kable(product_accounts, digits = 3)
product physical_unit_cost physical_total_cost net_revenue producer_profit government_revenue
a 0.586 32.495 91.576 59.081 22.894
b 0.786 18.171 42.799 24.629 10.700
c 1.680 20.602 29.466 8.864 0.000
d 1.911 10.555 14.372 3.817 0.000
account_totals <- function(x) c(
  gross_revenue = sum(x$gross_revenue), net_revenue = sum(x$net_revenue),
  physical_total_cost = sum(x$physical_cost * x$q),
  producer_profit = sum(x$producer_profit),
  government_revenue = sum(x$government_revenue))
knitr::kable(rbind(pre = account_totals(pre), post = account_totals(post)),
             digits = 3)
gross_revenue net_revenue physical_total_cost producer_profit government_revenue
pre 212.920 212.920 83.327 129.592 0.000
post 211.808 178.214 81.823 96.391 33.594

For every product, physical producer profit plus government revenue equals (price - physical_cost) * q. This is an accounting identity over the included producers, not a finding about national welfare or the nationality of a firm. The totals table sums all included products: for example, net revenue minus physical total cost equals producer profit. Government receipts are separate from net seller revenue.

Consumer change and margin units

welfare <- tariff_welfare(scenario)
fields <- c("physical_producer_surplus_delta",
            "importing_government_revenue_delta", "consumer_variation",
            "monetary_consumer_change")
knitr::kable(data.frame(measure = fields,
  change = unlist(welfare[fields], use.names = FALSE)), digits = 3)
measure change
physical_producer_surplus_delta -33.202
importing_government_revenue_delta 33.594
consumer_variation 6.424
monetary_consumer_change -6.424

The first two entries are monetary changes from the baseline. Positive consumer variation means compensation required for a price increase; monetary consumer change is its negative. Producer scope is all included producers and government scope is the importing government. Their accounting sum does not by itself establish a national or exact global welfare measure.

The accounts also distinguish net_margin, profit per unit of net seller revenue; physical_unit_profit = (1-tau)*price-physical_cost; and effective_unit_markup = price-effective_cost. These have different units and cannot be substituted for one another at a nonzero tariff.

Choose a starting point

What you have Operation Meaning
Observed inputs and an implemented calibration model calibrate() Estimate structural parameters from those inputs
Supplied structural parameters specify() Build the specified structural game
A compatible fitted game as_trade_fit() Attach the policy contract without refitting
A fitted policy game and a scenario simulate() Solve the requested counterfactual

trade::supportedModels() lists complete implementations and their supported operations. Native coordination games are promoted from their own constructors; their registry entries do not create new trade calibration APIs. Updating inputs, respecifying a model and simulating a policy have distinct meanings.

Retention, ownership and limitations

Ownership remains actual ownership; seller retention is separate state. With uniform retention within each firm, an effective-cost transformation preserves its optimization problem. Mixed tariffs within a portfolio require the retained-revenue equations. Multiplying an ownership row by a tariff vector is not a universal correction, and a tariff alone must not be added again as a physical mcDelta shock.

At a nonzero baseline tariff, effective-cost and net-revenue margin bases must be compatible with the fitted source; declaring bases cannot repair an incompatible likelihood or prior. This example holds fitted demand and physical costs fixed. Calibrated predictions are sensitive to inputs and assumptions; ordinary deterministic output supplies no automatic sampling uncertainty.

Supported ordinary fitted-game sequential paths can include ownership, cost, entry and exit changes. Entry is restricted to supported source models. Native Stackelberg/core-fringe paths require explicit roles after ownership changes and do not support entry. The explicit TariffGameFit route does not handle quotas.

Continue with a binding quota (source) or quantity-setting tariffs (source). See ?as_trade_fit, ?TariffGameFit, ?tariff_accounts and ?tariff_welfare for exact contracts. The mathematical reference retains model theory; fitted-game reuse covers advanced baseline and posterior conditions.